“He’s Kind Of Old”: Superman Legacy’s Green Lantern Casting Splits DCU Fans

by Barbara

The DC Extended Universe (DCU) has been a topic of much discussion and speculation over the years, with fans eagerly awaiting news of new castings and storylines. One of the most recent controversies to rock the DCU fandom is the casting of an older actor as the new Green Lantern, with some fans praising the decision while others express their disappointment. The debate centers around the perceived departure from the traditional age range of Green Lantern characters and the implications it may have for the future of the franchise.

1. The Traditional Age Range of Green Lantern Characters

Traditionally, the Green Lantern Corps has been portrayed as an intergalactic police force made up of individuals from various species and planets. While the specific age of each Green Lantern varies, they have generally been depicted as relatively young and fit individuals. This depiction aligns with the idea that the Green Lantern ring chooses individuals who possess exceptional willpower and courage, traits often associated with youth and vitality.


2. The Legacy of Superman and the Impact on Green Lantern Casting

One of the key factors fueling the controversy is the casting decision’s connection to the legacy of Superman. It has been widely reported that Warner Bros. intends to retire Henry Cavill’s Superman character in the upcoming DC films. With the retirement of a younger Superman, some fans argue that the casting of an older Green Lantern is a deliberate choice to fill the void left by Superman and provide a seasoned and mature hero in the DCU.


3. The Pros and Cons of an Older Green Lantern

The casting of an older actor as Green Lantern brings both advantages and disadvantages to the DCU. Let’s examine some of the key points raised by fans on both sides of the debate:


a) Advantages:

Seasoned Experience: An older Green Lantern could bring a wealth of experience and wisdom to the character, making him a more nuanced and complex hero. This interpretation could resonate with fans who appreciate a more mature and introspective approach to superheroes.

Contrasting Dynamics: A dynamic shift in the DCU could occur if a younger generation of heroes, such as Wonder Woman and the Flash, coexist with a seasoned Green Lantern. This could create interesting dynamics and storytelling opportunities, as younger heroes could learn from the older Green Lantern’s experiences and vice versa.

b) Disadvantages:

Deviation from Source Material: The decision to cast an older actor as Green Lantern could be seen as a departure from the established canon and the traditional depiction of the character. This might disappoint fans who prefer faithful adaptations of their favorite comic book heroes.

Limited Longevity: An older actor might have a limited lifespan in the role, potentially limiting the character’s potential for future appearances and franchise expansion. This could create continuity challenges and prevent the establishment of a long-term character arc for the Green Lantern.

4. Embracing Change and Creative Freedom

Comic book adaptations often face the challenge of balancing fan expectations with the need for creative freedom. While it is essential to honor the source material and satisfy fans, taking risks and exploring new interpretations can also lead to exciting storytelling possibilities.

The casting of an older Green Lantern could be seen as a bold move by Warner Bros. and DC Comics to diversify their superhero lineup and explore different facets of the character. By breaking away from established conventions, they have the opportunity to create a fresh and unique take on the Green Lantern mythology.

5. The Importance of Quality Storytelling

Ultimately, regardless of the casting choice, the success of any superhero film or TV series hinges on the quality of the storytelling. It is vital for the creative team to craft a compelling narrative that resonates with audiences, regardless of the age of the actor playing Green Lantern.

Fans should remember that casting decisions are made based on a multitude of factors, including the director’s vision, the story’s requirements, and the actor’s suitability for the role. The casting of an older Green Lantern might align with the narrative and character development planned for the DCU, offering an opportunity for a rich and layered portrayal.

6. Conclusion: Finding Common Ground

While the casting of an older actor as Green Lantern has undoubtedly sparked controversy and divided the DCU fandom, it is crucial to approach the situation with an open mind. Instead of clinging to rigid expectations and preconceived notions, fans should embrace the potential for new and exciting storytelling possibilities.

By encouraging dialogue and respectful debate, fans can contribute to a thriving and inclusive fan community. Regardless of personal preferences, the ultimate goal should be to support the creative endeavors of Warner Bros. and DC Comics, as they continue to expand and evolve the DCU for audiences around the world.

As the casting controversy continues to unfold, only time will tell whether an older Green Lantern will win over skeptics and leave a lasting legacy in the DC Extended Universe.



You may also like


Rnada is a movie portal. The main columns include trailers, movie reviews, celebrities, movie knowledge, news

Copyright © 2023