Julia Ducournau’s latest film Alpha captivates viewers with its intense visual style but struggles under the weight of its ambitious thematic scope, resulting in a narrative that feels scattered and unfocused. The story follows a 13-year-old girl named Alpha (played by Melissa Borochov), who, after getting a tattoo at a party, faces the terrifying possibility of contracting a mysterious virus. This virus causes the body to gradually turn into stone-like marble, serving as a metaphor for the fear and stigma surrounding AIDS during the 1990s. Alpha’s mother (portrayed by Golshifteh Farahani), a doctor, becomes increasingly anxious about her daughter’s potential infection.
The threat of the virus also brings Alpha’s estranged uncle Amin (played by Tahar Rahim) back into her life. Amin, a gaunt and troubled man addicted to heroin, carries a mix of charisma and menace. Although the performances are compelling, the film attempts to explore numerous heavy themes—addiction, infection, family tension, social ostracism—without dedicating enough focus to any single one. This overload leaves the narrative feeling congested and lacking emotional depth.
Within the film, Alpha is bullied at school as her classmates fear contagion, illustrating society’s fear and marginalization of those afflicted by disease. Meanwhile, Amin’s heroin addiction portrays a parallel form of self-destruction. While this contrast holds promise, the film fails to build strong emotional connections or balance between the two characters’ arcs. Unfortunately, the story shifts much of its attention toward Alpha’s attempts to unravel her uncle’s mysterious past, neglecting the mother’s internal conflict between protecting her daughter and saving her brother. This missed opportunity weakens the film’s emotional core.
Interspersed throughout the movie are warm and poignant flashbacks that reveal the complex family dynamics and cultural background, such as gatherings during Eid and conversations in Berber language. These details enrich the story’s texture but do not fully cohere into a unified narrative. Ducournau’s visual prowess remains undeniable, with powerful imagery and symbolism enhancing the film’s atmosphere. Yet critics note that if the director had exercised more restraint in theme selection and clearer narrative focus, Alpha would have delivered a more potent and moving experience.
In summary, Alpha is a film marked by creative ambition and artistic talent, showcasing bold visual storytelling. However, its attempt to incorporate multiple heavy elements ultimately overshadows the emotional and thematic core it aims to convey. The result is a work caught between striking expression and narrative coherence, still searching for balance.
Related Topics
- Indonesian Animated Film Jumbo Breaks Box Office Records
- Cannes Film Festival Stars Defy New Red Carpet Dress Code
- Does Moana Have a Sister in Moana 2?