Since its debut, the TV series Supernatural has become a beloved show known for its gripping plot and the deep bond between its central characters, brothers Dean and Sam Winchester. Over 15 seasons and 327 episodes, it became the longest-running show on the CW network, maintaining strong ratings throughout its run. Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki’s portrayals of Dean and Sam have been widely praised as some of television’s most iconic brotherly roles.
While the final season’s ending sparked controversy among fans, many believe the show’s original planned ending at the close of season five was more satisfying. Creator Eric Kripke initially envisioned the series as a five-season arc, with an epic finale that featured a biblical battle to prevent the apocalypse. This season five finale received critical acclaim and remains the highest-rated episode of the series.
Season Five Finale Nearly Perfect but Leaves Questions
The fifth season ended with Sam sacrificing himself to trap Lucifer and stop the apocalypse, protecting Dean and the world. This dramatic and emotional moment has become a classic in the series. However, the story leaves one puzzling detail: Sam is trapped in Hell with little chance of escape, while Dean chooses to leave hunting behind and live a peaceful life with his wife, Lisa.
Many viewers find this decision difficult to accept. Given Dean’s deep love for his brother, why doesn’t he try to save Sam? This inconsistency stands out, especially considering Dean’s earlier relentless efforts to rescue Sam. This unresolved issue became a key reason for continuing the story in later seasons.
Later Seasons Expand the Winchester Brothers and Castiel’s Story
In the following six seasons, Sam is brought back to life, though without his soul, through a deal made between the angel Castiel and the demon Crowley. These seasons add depth to the relationship between the Winchester brothers and give more focus to Castiel, who quickly became a fan favorite.
This continuation breathed new life into Supernatural, allowing the show to explore the characters and their conflicts more deeply. While the original ending had its flaws, it opened the door for richer storytelling and character development.
Original Ending Preferred Over Controversial Series Finale
Although the final season’s conclusion divided fans—with some seeing it as rushed and weak—the original five-season ending is viewed as more impactful and complete. The final episode of the series, which shows Dean’s death and his reunion with Sam in Heaven, offers a peaceful and emotional closure but lacks the intensity of the earlier finale.
Overall, many fans consider the five-season ending the true high point of Supernatural, delivering a complete and emotionally powerful story. Yet some plot choices, especially Dean’s acceptance of Sam’s fate without further attempts to save him, continue to spark debate among viewers and critics.
Related Topics:
- Loretta Swit, Emmy Winner from ‘MAS*H,’ Dead at 87
- ‘Andor’ Showrunner Confirms $650M Cost, Disney Declares “Streaming Is Dead”
- Adults Explores the Growing Pains of 20-Somethings in NYC